Thursday, May 12, 2011

Transmedia Brands: Are Automobiles the Pioneer of Transmedia Storytelling in Non-Entertainment Products?

Most of the transmedia scholars and practitioners agree that transmedia storytelling (TM) is not limited to entertainment contexts but also applicable to a wide variety of non-entertainment brands including political figures like Obama, consumer goods like Coca Cola, or sport franchises like WWE. Transmedia is an equally relevant and lucrative strategy for non-entertainment brands. Audi 5, for example, is found out to be one of the most engaged brands on Facebook and, similarly, Coca Cola, Starbucks, and Obama are among the most popular Facebook fan pages in a list surrounded by several entertainment brands like Eminem, Gaga, and Bieber. Despite its huge potential, transmedia hasn’t fully utilized this promise in non-entertainment product categories. In the contemporary marketplace, every product and brand has the entertainment zest or at least the potential for it. In Rob Kozinets’s words:

‘Consumer culture and pop entertainment culture have collided and intermingled…Soda pop and pop culture. Marketed together, and marketed the same ways.’
I am very much interested in transmedia brands and how TM can be utilized by brand managers to tell stories of brands across social and traditional media platforms. While trying to understand the extent and the ways transmedia can be applied to non-entertainment products, I came across several examples of automobiles\cars that employed these transmedia principles as part of their IMC and branding strategies. Full-fledged transmedia projects that use variety of media platforms where stories are systematically distributed and coordinated are still very limited in number. Even in this particular product category. Yet, some IMC campaigns of cars -- although in varying degrees -- make use of TM principles: creating intertextual, layered and complex brand stories, coordination and use of multiple media platforms to disperse some back stories, and worldbuilding.

Creating and perpetuating deep brand meaning through narrative –– the narrative view of brands–– is not new to marketing scholars. Although a brand’s use of stories is not sufficient to label any IMC campaign as transmedia, I think, it is an important early stage of transmediation. In a marketplace and mediascape where most of the brand building and brand development strategies are dominated by studying brands as collective of associations –– attributes or benefits that differentiate a brand from competing brands –– changing the lens to the narrative view would definitely help with the transition of non-entertainment brands to the transmedia-scape.

Several car brands recently adopted this narrative view. In spite of the general car commercials that focus on the attributes of the cars like reliability, precision (e.g. Honda ) safety etc. , Toyota’s Happy Camry Family commercial, for example, portrays  each family member telling his or her own experiences and memories of Toyota Camry.  Some brand stories also embed cultural references into their stories. This intertextuality is an important characteristic of layered and complex transmedia narratives. Chrysler’s very recent Super Bowl ad story-fies this American-made car brand using the intertwined stories of the Detroit City, the American car produced for the American people, and industrialization in US. The commercial stresses that this is the backstory of Chrysler as told by the people living in that Motor City. Moreover, Eminem’s story as a rebellious rapper from Detroit adds some depth and layer to Chrysler’s brand story.  Similarly, the latest Volkswagen commercial The Force uses one of the well-known cultural references of the American popular culture – Star Wars.  The commercial, in a very emotionally engaging way, tells the story of a girl who is in love with Star Wars –– the pink rooms, the dolls, yes I think it is a girl –– and her failed attempts of using her Force.

Besides using narratives and cultural references, some IMC campaigns perform worldbuilding practices through coordinated storytelling across a multitude of media platforms. By creating stories that cannot be fully explored within a single work or even a single medium, these producers court consumers across media platforms. This is one of the basic principles of transmedia storytelling. In 2001, BMW released The Hire campaign, an eight-part web series directed by eight major filmmakers, including Guy Ritchie and John Woo starring Clive Owen ad Madonna. Over 21 million people watched the series on the web in its first year alone, and in four years the series has been watched by over 100 million viewers. In addition to DVDs and streaming, BMW extended the storytelling to comic books. The Hire campaign illustrates the successful integration of content and media in an integrated marketing communications campaign to build brand visibility and awareness in a new younger target market. In addition to cross-platform consumption, The Hire also assisted with the community building for the brand.

Simiarly, Audi launched the Audi Heist campaign in 2006.  The campaign started with a viral video showing Audi 3 getting stolen from the dealership a night before the car was supposed to make its first appearance in one of the biggest auto shows in America. Participants got involved in the mission to find the stolen car by following bits and pieces of the puzzle in various mediums like ARG (Alternate Reality Game), Yellow Pages, flyers, across the Net, newspapers, and magazines. Producers’ attention to detail and authenticity in this campaign showed the importance of coordination in TM branding campaigns.

Although on a smaller scale, Mini’s latest mobile hunting game uses a similar mobile-offline transmedia involvement with the brand. Mini’s “Capture the Mini Stockholm” campaign asks participants to hunt and catch a virtual Mini in Stockholm using their mobile apps. Participants locate the virtual Mini on their app, try to get 50m close to it, and then get (possess) this virtual car.  Any other participant who gets within 50 meters can steal the car away from then-possessing participant. The objective of the game is to get\catch the virtual Mini and also to protect it for a week. If you have the Mini on your phone for a week of gaming, you win a real Mini Countryman.  So don’t be surprised if you see people running away from you on Stockholm streets ;p

Following its pioneer role in The Hire, BMW has recently started the Activate the Future campaign to create some awareness before the launch of their first electric car, BMW ActiveE.  Activate the Future campaign focuses on the concept of the future of mobility.  The campaign uses several media platforms to tell the story of the future and the mobility from the perspectives of astronauts, futurists, designers, city planners and so on. Activate the Future campaign uses documentaries, Facebook fan pages, mobile apps, twitter accounts, and also links to some books about the future and the city as media platforms. I am following BMW’s Activate the Future “Wherever You Want To Go” campaign very closely. I will blog about BMW ActiveE more in the coming weeks. Seeing Faris Yakob, a familiar name for the transmedia circles, in the steering wheel of this campaign makes me more curious about how Activate the Future campaign would unfold. Faris,  hints at the transmedia idea behind the documentaries and other media as: "The films are designed to be non-linear and hypertextual. You can explore additional pieces of content around the primary narrative."

In short, the ways we use stories for branding have changed. We have come long way from using BMW’s in James Bond’s movies as product placements. Although those were also very creative use of marketing tools at the time, we don’t only put brands in stories anymore but we create and develop stories around and about brands. My objective with this post is neither to present some recipes about extending transmedia to non-entertainment products nor to provide a roadmap. I am doing that in a journal paper. Talking about transmedia ;-) In this post, I am just playing with the question: In spite of the sporadic and idiosyncratic use of transmedia principles in non-entertainment contexts, might these many examples in a specific product category point out to a pattern that we should study further?

Unfortunately, as transmedia scholars and practitioners, our discussions are still focused on defining what transmedia is or what is not. At this juncture, more interesting questions about transmedia explore the possible and relevant manifestations of the concept like transmedia consumption (my dissertation explores that. Stay tuned!), transmedia branding, transmedia education, or transmedia activism.

What can we learn from the use of TM  in the above examples so that we can expand the application of transmedia branding strategies to wide-variety of non-entertainment brands? Can automobiles\cars be the pioneer product category that better lends itself to transmediation compared to other non-entertainment products?Is transmedia branding a good strategy for some products or brands and not for others?


Monday, May 2, 2011

Against My Grain [Question Mark]

My blogging adventure - from idea stage to the implementation - had been a spotty one...starting with Tumblr as a new year resolution in January 2010, then resuming my two Blogger accounts that I signed up in early 2008. My Tumblr found a path for itself that is very different than I intended. I let it be....Yet, regardless of the site - Tumblr or Blogger, the first post of my blogs is " Against My Grain [Question Mark] ". Let's stick with the ritual.


"“Why?”… This is the question I have to answer to myself.  Why do I really want to blog? I have felt complete without a blog until this day. So, why now? Maybe I am just looking for a new toy to curb my appetite for a while and then throw aside. First Facebook then twitter, 100 gram LinkedIn, and some other platforms that I am hiding in plain sight ….Maybe I am simply looking for a new medium to explore; just a new way of BEING. 

I was telling my mom about my new year resolutions and that’s how the blogging conversation came up. She is not a media addict of any form like many of us are. I explained her what a blog is and its format.  While telling her, my words sounded flat even to myself.   With a smirk on her face that I know since the early days of my childhood, she looked at my face and said in a voice pretending to be naive: “So, it is like talking to yourself.”  I wish she didn't see through things this clearly. I wish she didn't know my hand going to my neck when I feel anxious, the sorrow at the tip of my lower lip, or  my pulsing eye when I try to hide something from her. My mom exposing me ...repeatedly... definitely a story for another post. About the blogging, she was right. As usual! When your mom is an attorney, you have to get used to her being right! ( I definitely developed some offensive strategies tough) :sigh: Maybe we started to be engaged in self conversations. Maybe we are scared that we will accidentally make people uncomfortable or intrude their lives if we address them personally. So we tell our part of the story and throw it in this endless abyss of words, texts, and noise.  With this blog I contribute to that entropy as well.

I always thought that blogging has somehow replaced the diary or scrap booking practice. I have never had a diary in my entire life. I used to scrapbook around middle school for a short while but was not keen on that either. I guess, I wasn’t one of those people who wanted to make everything tangible on a notebook page in print or on a photo shoot filtered through a camera lens. I have always thought that these type of efforts are aimed at stopping the time or make life more tangible. The meaning of life for me is not in these frozen and constructed moments but more in between them and definitely not 42. While you are trying to adjust the camera to take the photo of fireworks or writing about life, the life itself parades in front of you. 

Another reason I don’t want to distribute my thoughts across the Net is the pace that my intellectual capital is evolving. What I think now and what I might think two weeks later about a particular subject might conflict. So along this journey, I keep my right to be in conflict with myself. That doesn’t mean I am wishy washy. I have a very strong spine. Sometimes stronger than necessary. I have strong and rooted positions, perspectives, and sensitivities on several topics. But more I learn, more I realize how less I know. I want to be the student of life as much as I can afford. The thirst and curiosity of knowing more changes me… deconstructs me and reconstructs me over and over. After these small metamorphoses, I look back and I feel proud of myself and of my growing and adapting ability.

Aside from the idea of blogging, I am also confused about the possible contents of my blog. I don’t want this to be the nth chapter of my dissertation. But I don’t want it to be the perfect opportunity for my cynical and critical political self to whine.  I hardly talk about my personal life on the Net or in any other public place for the truth of the matter. So, that’s left out, too. Memories…..NO! I have some memories that I am too jealous to share and tell even to myself. I keep them at the dearest part of my memory and only bring out at certain times with care.   I feel like they will get less if I put them into words…I keep the memory of smells, whispers, heartbreaks, stomach cramps, kisses, tears, winks, smiles,  laughters, and stares that I cannot  and, above all, do not want to share with anyone. So , I am really stuck as to what to tell here. I go back to square one….If I don’t know what to say, why do I want to blog?  Gelin ata binmiş ya nasip! (A Turkish idiom. The ones who know the meaning of the idiom should explain to the ones who don’t )

So I take it easy…. I will write when I want, what I want about…. Maybe I will delete them on the way. That’s probably why I named my blog “Printed on the Water”. I thought about the title for a while. Coupled with my love for water, I like the idea of writing on the water.  Sharing it with water and letting it adopt everything you have written. I don’t think what I will say is too serious to be written in stone and to be kept permanently. I am aware that I am just a very small part of this endless social construction.

I think my biggest motivation for writing anything expressive is driven by my itches. My statuses, my tweets, and even my dissertation are all products of my itches and brain itches… of the ones I can scratch and the ones I cannot. Brain itches…unfortunately I had too many of those as well. Throughout my life, I have suffered from an overworking brain as much as I have benefited from it. So I sometimes question whether having a working mind is a gift or a curse. This blog might be a way to scratch these brain itches I had for a long while….at least to sooth them.  *rolling eyes* I have another blog titled "Brain Itches of a Heretic" where I would more write about those itches.

This is the  baby step… When I grow up in this blogging game or if I ever grow up… I want to be like my Yoda, aka Rob Kozinets and write a blog like his – Brandthroposophy."

I Blog...